Karsten's Blog

May 17, 2013

Remove “Build path specifies execution environment…” warnings from Problems View

Filed under: Eclipse — Tags: , , , — kthoms @ 9:27 AM

I have often workspaces with projects which specify Java 1.5 as minimal execution environment. On my machine there is no JDK 1.5 installed, and it turns out that getting one for Mac OSX Mountain Lion is not trivial. Actually I don’t need a JDK 1.5, since the standard 1.6 JDK is compatible. However, this raises in the workspace these annoying warnings.

screenshot 2013-05-17 um 10.32.31

In the Execution Environments setting it is possible to mark the Java 1.6 installation as compatible to the J2SE-1.5 Execution Environment:

screenshot 2013-05-17 um 10.52.31

Although the JDK 1.6 is marked compatible now, it is not “strictly compatible”, so the warning message remains.

Next you could try to disable the warning message. There is a setting for this in the preference dialog Java/Compiler/Building:

screenshot 2013-05-17 um 10.35.17

After changing the setting you are asked to rebuild the projects. But again, the warning do not disappear. I suspect this to be a bug and raised Bug#408317 for this.

So the last chance is to filter these warnings. Therefore select the options menu in the Problems View and open the “Configure Contents” dialog. In the “Types” selection tree expand the “Java Build Path Problems” node and uncheck “JRE System Library Problem”.

screenshot 2013-05-17 um 11.03.53

Finally the warning messages disappear from the Problems View. However, they are just filtered from the view, the projects themselves will still have these resource markers, so you will have a warning overlay icon on the project in the Package Explorer View although the Problems View might be empty.

But this raises the next problem: Now the warning disappears and the code is compiled with Java 1.6, and thus against the 1.6 API. This leads to the problem that you could accidently use API from >= 1.6. For example, usage of String#isEmpty() would compile even if the Execution Environment is set to J2SE-1.5 (the Execution Environment anyway just defines the lowest requirement) and also if Java source compatibility is set to 1.6 in the compiler settings.

We need to detect this unwanted use of API that is not 1.5 compatible. Therefore the PDE tooling offers support to install an Execution Environment Description for J2SE-1.5 and set up API tooling. This will finally allow us to detect illegal API use:

screenshot 2013-05-17 um 14.00.15

I like to thank Laurent Goubet and Mikael Barbero for their valuable comments on the potential API problems.

April 5, 2013

Preparations for CodeGeneration 2013

Filed under: MDSD, Xtext — Tags: , , , , , — kthoms @ 10:44 AM

As I am addicted to code generation and DSLs, the CodeGeneration conference in Cambridge is always a must each year. Last year I could not make it, since I had the chance to speak at EclipseCon North America, which was in the same week. This year Mark took EclipseCon into his considerations (it was last week), so me and my colleagues from itemis will be there again. Actually, this year we will be more itemis guys then ever. Mark already assumed in his opening words at CG2011 that almost everyone from itemis would be there, this year we prove itemis is larger. I think our company is so close related to the conference theme that it is natural that we have lots to present, and much interest to hear others about what they are doing and have learned in the past.

screenshot 2013-04-05 um 10.55.19

Before the actual CodeGeneration conference starts on Wednesday, there are some pre-conference activities. My colleagues Holger Schill and Moritz Eysholdt will hold an intensive 2-day Xtext workshop on monday and tuesday.

I will arrive monday noon, since I take the early flight directly from my hometown Dortmund to London Luton. From there, I have to take a 2 hour bus trip to Cambridge. In the evening, I plan to meet Holger, Moritz, Meinte Boersma and hopefully some others in the Castle Inn pub. When you arrive on monday, drop into the Castle Inn roughly at 20 PM (I guess we go to a restaurant before). You can reach me there on my mobile phone: screenshot 2013-04-05 um 12.30.02


On tuesday this year’s Language Workbench Challenge summit takes place. We have 14 submissions (wow!) for the LWC13 assignment. I have been working on the Xtext submission together with 2 colleagues, Johannes Dicks and Thomas Kutz. The results are available as open-source project lwc13-xtext at Eclipselabs. We have prepared a detailed step-by-step tutorial as submission paper. The resulting document LWC13-XtextSubmission.pdf is available for download. On the project homepage I have placed today a quick start tutorial. Oh boy, this project did cost some time. The actual solution is not much code, but as often, it is harder to write less code than more. It could be even less, but we took care of that the code is readable and understandable. And writing the document is at least that much work as the implementation.

screenshot 2013-04-08 um 13.52.06

Every presenter has only 15 minutes to present their approach. 15 minutes presentation for that much work. I guess that the other participants did invest also quite some time. Both of my co-authors got the chance to visit the conference, and Thomas will support me with the presentation. He will demo the resulting JSF application and DSL source code while I do the main talking. We did a test run of the talk yesterday evening, and easily exceeded 20 minutes. I think Angelo will bring his egg timer again, which begs no pardon with the talk time of speakers. But only that way we will be able to run 14 talks on one day. We will have to restrict on the most important aspects only.

Besides my colleagues Thomas and Johannes also Sven Lange will join us then. I have the pleasure to work with him in my long-time project at Deutsche Börse (German Stock Exchange), now since over half a year. Sven is a highly motivated, skilled and smart person. It is still the same project I have reported about at CodeGeneration 2009 together with my former colleague Heiko Behrens. Sven is full-time working on this project, while I am for 20% scheduled. We have migrated here a huge code generator project from Xpand to Xtend. This alone would be worth an experience report session. Sven is working on Xtend support for IntelliJ, which he might present in a Lightning Talk on wednesday.

Wednesday the conference will start. I will have my main talk “Alive and Kicking with Code Generation” together with Dr. Boris Baginski from ATOSS Software AG after lunch at 13:45.

screenshot 2013-04-05 um 10.57.34

Currently we are finalizing our presentation slides. Boris has been ill for some days and busy with a new release of their ASES product, a workforce management suite. This is really an interesting customer and project. They are evolving this product now for 25 years, and they make use of code generation for ages. I think one can say that it helped them to survive in their business, some contestants did not manage to make larger platform shifts and died. Most of them tried a big-bang replacement, but the business is too fast evolving so that the target is moving steadily. Boris and I will speak about this product and how it has been evolved over the years. ATOSS was one of the first major projects using openArchitectureWare 4 (which mainly means Xpand), and now they are currently preparing a shift to Xtend.

I am glad that this talk is already on wednesday, I never come to rest until I finished some talk. After it, I can just relax and enjoy the conference. I am expecting some interesting insights on different approaches. Especially experience reports are interesting for me. I did not finally decide which sessions I will attend. At the moment I plan to see John Hutchinson with “The Use of Model-Driven Development in Industry” in the morning, and Darius Silingas with “Why MDA Fails: Analysis of Unsuccessful Cases” in the afternoon.

In the evening it is again time for the punting boat tour. I already attended three times, but it will be great fun again for sure. Let’s hope the weather is not too bad. I saw a prediction of ~10°C and possibility of light shower. In the past we had luck, and on a warm, sunny day the tour is double fun. However, I’ll better put an umbrella into the suitcase.

On thursday I have again an active part in the hands-on session “Have Your Language Built While You Wait”, which is hosted by Risto Pohjonen from MetaCase. The idea of this session is that attendees can get a DSL with the language workbench of their choice built with the help of experts for this workbench. Of course I will assist on Xtext. If you had no chance to visit the Xtext workshop this might be your chance to get some hands on Xtext. This session was already run last year successfully. Last year my colleague Benjamin Schwertfeger took over the Xtext part, since we were at EclipseCon.

There are also some other talks around Xtext and Xtend. Both have been released in version 2.4 on March 20th, which brings some interesting new features. Most notably in regard to code generation are the Active Annotations. I guess this is also part of what Sven Efftinge will adress as future of code generation in his keynote “The Past, Present and Future of Code Generation” wednesday morning. More details he will present together with Sebastian Zarnekow in the tutorial “Internal DSLs with Xtend” (thursday 10:45-12:00). The last Xtext related talk will be from Moritz Eysholdt, called “Executable Specifications for Xtext Languages” (friday 10:45-12:15). I am actually not sure which of these talks I will attend personally. They are most relevant for my work, and I don’t work close enough with them to catch everything new in Xtext on my own. Thus, I’ll definetely would learn important aspects. On the other side, there are also other interesting talks in parallel.

The coming week will be an intensive experience with lots to learn and interesting persons to meet. Although I will really enjoy this time, I will be glad when I finally come back home. At the moment, my family is ill and I hope that I get not infected these days. I have been looking forward and worked for this event, so I am crossing fingers when I can board monday morning healthy.

I am sure the organizing team around Mark and Jacqui will do again a great job.


See you there and let’s make this event special!

May 22, 2012

Xtext Content Assist: Filtering keyword proposals

Filed under: Xtext — Tags: — kthoms @ 8:37 PM

Sometimes when I introduce template proposals in Xtext editors I want them to be a replacement for a keyword proposal. By default you would get a proposal for the template AND for the keyword. In the following screenshot a template for a “class” concept exists, and a proposal for the “class” keyword, which would be inserted as part of the template at the cursor position.

The key to the solution is to overwrite the completeKeyword() method from your proposal provider class, e.g. like this:

public class SprayProposalProvider extends AbstractSprayProposalProvider {
    private static final Set<String>      FILTERED_KEYWORDS = Sets.newHashSet("text", "line", "class", "behavior", "style", "custom");
    public void completeKeyword(Keyword keyword, ContentAssistContext contentAssistContext, ICompletionProposalAcceptor acceptor) {
        if (FILTERED_KEYWORDS.contains(keyword.getValue())) {
            // don't propose keyword
        super.completeKeyword(keyword, contentAssistContext, acceptor);

Christian Dietrich added in a comment how to filter a keyword that may occur more than once in your grammar. If you want to filter specific occurances you need to use the IGrammarAccess of your language:

@Inject MyDslGrammarAccess grammarAccess;

public void completeKeyword(Keyword keyword,ContentAssistContext contentAssistContext,ICompletionProposalAcceptor acceptor) {
  if (!grammarAccess.getGreetingAccess().getHelloKeyword_0().equals(keyword)) {
    super.completeKeyword(keyword, contentAssistContext, acceptor);

Fornax Workflow Plugin 3.4.0 released

Filed under: Eclipse, Maven — Tags: , , — kthoms @ 8:23 PM

Finally I have managed to release a new version of the Fornax Maven Workflow Plugin again. This Maven plugin allows execution of MWE and MWE2 workflows from Maven, which is typically the case if you want to automate the build of Xtext or Xpand based projects with Maven.

The new version has some interesting new features which may be worth upgrading:

  • m2e lifecycle metadata
  • workflow dependencies can be configured as plugin dependencies
  • more options to detect changes that trigger the build
  • force/skip parameter to configure workflow execution overrides per configuration
  • log level detection when running in forked JVM

I have especially to thank Dieter Schulten from escalon, who has been willing to contribute to this release. He has mainly contributed the m2e configuration and some tests for the plugin.

April 26, 2012

xtext-utils unittesting 0.9.4 released

Filed under: Xtext — Tags: — kthoms @ 3:20 PM

I have just released the new version 0.9.4 of the xtext-utils unittesting framework. The release became necessary due to a too restrictive version constraint for Google Guice, which made the framework incompatible with the upcoming Xtext 2.3.0 release.

This little framework is a useful addition to Xtext which makes writing DSL tests quite easy. In my daily work on developing Xtext projects and coaching Xtext in workshops it became a useful tool which complements Xtext’s test support. It is not the only way to write tests for Xtext DSLs, but a real simple one. The main idea is that the best way to develop DSLs is to write prototype models. This framework allows you to read, parse, validate, format, serialize, and compare your models in a single line.

The framework can be installed from its update site.

April 17, 2012

Unofficial release 2.2.2 of the Xtend Maven Plugin

Filed under: Maven, Spray, Xtext — Tags: , , — kthoms @ 5:52 AM

In my previous post I showed how to use the maven-xtend-plugin to compile Xtend sources within a Maven build. This worked fine in simple cases, but there was a limitation of only one supported source directory (the one configured by build/sourceDirectory property), see Bug#367914. Unfortunately already each Xtext project has already 2 source folders (src and src-gen), so this made the plugin unusable for Xtext projects and forced checking in the generated Java files. This causes terrible problems with version control, especially when working on a team.

In the meantime Bug#367914 was resolved, but only for the upcoming Xtend 2.3 (Eclipse Juno) version. This urgent bugfix was not available on a Maven repository. But I needed it for project Spray to finally get rid of the merge conflicts and delete the generated sources from the repository (issue#94). Spray is still using Xtext/Xtend version 2.2.1 and depends on public available Maven artifacts. Since the bugfix won’t be available from the Xtend project for the 2.2.1 release and Eclipse Juno is still some way to go I decided to backport the current 2.3.0 M6 sources of the Xtend Maven Plugin to 2.2.x and create an unofficial version 2.2.2. This plugin I have deployed to the Fornax Repository to make it public available.

For an usage example refer to the POMs of project Spray: pom.xml, parent pom.xml.

April 3, 2012

JvmType import check

Filed under: Spray, Xtext — Tags: , — kthoms @ 1:47 PM

Several Xtext based DSLs will use import statements that import JvmTypes, be them real Java types, or just inferred types produced with your IJvmModelInferrer. The check for a valid import might be simple, but here it is to just make it even easier for you. I just had the need to realize this to resolve Spray issue#113. Basically you need to get the IJvmTypeProvider, to which you gain access through the IJvmTypeProvider.Factory.

public class SprayJavaValidator extends AbstractSprayJavaValidator implements IssueCodes {
    private IJvmTypeProvider.Factory typeProviderFactory;
    public void checkImports(final Import imp) {
        // don't check wildcard imports
        if (imp.getImportedNamespace().endsWith(".*"))
        IJvmTypeProvider typeProvider = typeProviderFactory.findOrCreateTypeProvider(imp.eResource().getResourceSet());
        JvmType jvmType = typeProvider.findTypeByName(imp.getImportedNamespace());
        if (jvmType == null) {
            error("The import " + imp.getImportedNamespace() + " cannot be resolved", SprayPackage.Literals.IMPORT__IMPORTED_NAMESPACE, IMPORT_NOTEXISTS, new String[0]);

That’s all.

March 15, 2012

Xtext Content Assist: Escape identifiers conflicting with keywords

Filed under: Spray, Xtext — Tags: , — kthoms @ 9:04 PM

I have faced in Spray the situation that a segment of a package name of a qualified Java type conflicts with a keyword of the Spray language. Specifically you can refer to custom features with the custom keyword, and the referred type was in a package containing also the name custom.

When inserting the proposed qualified name this results in an error due to the keyword collision.

The qualified name is usually combined through a sequence of ID rules, which allows escaping an identifier by prefixing it with the ^ character in the case of conflict with a keyword.

For content assist it would now be useful if the inserted string would be automatically escaped. So here is a way to solve this.

My first approach was to override the completeJvmParameterizedTypeReference_Type() method from the proposal provider and modify the proposals through a custom ICompletionProposalAcceptor. Sebastian Zarnekow commented that the proper way would be to register a IValueConverter for QualifiedName. I tried to do so, but was not successful. Actually there is already an QualifiedNameValueConverter registered.

My next solution is now to subclass JdtTypesProposalProvider and pass a custom IValueConverter. The overridden methods just pass null as converter, thus do no conversion. I am reusing the QualifiedNameValueConverter here, since it does the necessary keyword escaping.

public class SprayJdtTypesProposalProvider extends JdtTypesProposalProvider {
    private QualifiedNameValueConverter qnValueConverter;

     * Overridden to pass a default value converter
    public void createSubTypeProposals(JvmType superType, ICompletionProposalFactory proposalFactory, ContentAssistContext context, EReference typeReference, Filter filter, ICompletionProposalAcceptor acceptor) {
        createSubTypeProposals(superType, proposalFactory, context, typeReference, filter, getConverter(), acceptor);

     * Overridden to pass a default value converter
    public void createTypeProposals(ICompletionProposalFactory proposalFactory, ContentAssistContext context, EReference typeReference, Filter filter, ICompletionProposalAcceptor acceptor) {
        createTypeProposals(proposalFactory, context, typeReference, filter, getConverter(), acceptor);

    private AbstractValueConverter<String> getConverter() {
        return new AbstractValueConverter<String>() {
             * Remove ^ character from escaped segments
            public String toValue(String string, INode node) throws ValueConverterException {
                return string.replace("^", "");

             * Escape segments colliding with keywords with ^ character
            public String toString(String value) throws ValueConverterException {
                // this converter will escape keywords with ^
                return qnValueConverter.toString(value);

This custom implementation must be bound to the UI module:

public class SprayUiModule extends AbstractSprayUiModule {
    public Class<? extends ITypesProposalProvider> bindITypesProposalProvider() {
        return SprayJdtTypesProposalProvider.class;

Now the inserted qualified type name will be automatically replaced.

March 14, 2012

How to limit proposed Java types to implementors of an interface

Filed under: Xtext — Tags: , , — kthoms @ 6:20 PM

When you develop a DSL that derives from Xbase you likely want to refer to Jvm types through a JvmTypeReference.

CustomBehavior :
    'custom' (name = ID | 'ref' realizedBy=JvmTypeReference) (label = STRING);

If you hit CTRL+SPACE at such a position in the editor, by default you will get all visible Java types proposed:

This is not really useful when it only makes sense to refer to specifc types. If you want to limit the proposals to just implementors of a specific interface, you can customize this in the proposal provider by overriding the method completeJvmParameterizedTypeReference_Type(). The following example from Spray shows limiting the types to implementors of Graphiti’s ICustomFeature interface in the context of Spray’s CustomBehavior:

public class SprayProposalProvider extends AbstractSprayProposalProvider {
    private IJvmTypeProvider.Factory      jvmTypeProviderFactory;
    private ITypesProposalProvider        typeProposalProvider;
    public void completeJvmParameterizedTypeReference_Type(EObject model, Assignment assignment, ContentAssistContext context, ICompletionProposalAcceptor acceptor) {
        if (EcoreUtil2.getContainerOfType(model, CustomBehavior.class) != null) {
            final IJvmTypeProvider jvmTypeProvider = jvmTypeProviderFactory.createTypeProvider(model.eResource().getResourceSet());
            // Graphiti specific
            final JvmType interfaceToImplement = jvmTypeProvider.findTypeByName(ICustomFeature.class.getName());
            typeProposalProvider.createSubTypeProposals(interfaceToImplement, this, context, SprayPackage.Literals.BEHAVIOR__REALIZED_BY, TypeMatchFilters.canInstantiate(), acceptor);
        } else {
            super.completeJvmParameterizedTypeReference_Type(model, assignment, context, acceptor);

Now you will get the desired subtypes as proposals:

Note that this does only limit proposals to certain types. It does not prevent you from actually referring to another type that you don’t get proposed. This needs to be restricted in your scope provider.

December 8, 2011

Xtext 2.2 finally brings Maven support for Xtend

Filed under: Eclipse, Maven, Xtext — Tags: , , , — kthoms @ 10:22 PM

I cannot tell how often I was asked since introduction of Xtend2 how to compile them in a Maven build. This was just not possible until now due to the problem that to load and compile an Xtend class it is necessary to compile all of the Java classes that the Xtend class on before, and Java classes might depend on Xtend classes to be translated in order to be compilable.

Xtext 2.2.0 was just released yesterday, and for me the most important new feature is direct support through the xtend-maven-plugin plugin. I could not hesitate to test this feature, and created a small example.


I have set up a small Maven project with 2 Java classes and 1 Xtend class that depend on each other.

To translate XtendClass1 to Java code and compile it requires that JavaClass1 is compiled before, and to compile JavaClass2 it is necessary that XtendClass is translated to Java code before.

Maven POM Configuration

I have decided to not use Maven Tycho for this example, and use the typical structure of an Eclipse project with usage of Xtend, i.e. sources in folder /src (instead /src/main/java) and xtend-gen to generate the Java code for Xtend classes to.


Since shortly Xtext artifacts are available on maven.eclipse.org. The new Maven plugin is available on http://build.eclipse.org/common/xtend/maven/



This small project setup requires just a mimimal set of dependencies to be configured:


Source folders

The main source folder src/ can be configured with the build/sourceDirectory setting, for xtend-gen we need the support of the build-helper-maven-plugin.


The xtend-gen folder must be emptied when executing mvn clean, this requires some additional configuration of the maven-clean-plugin.



Now let’s finally come to the Xtend plugin. The plugin is configured as follows:


The outputDirectory is optional, but leaving it out the sources are generated to src/main/xtend-gen, and we want to generate to xtend-gen in the project root.

The plugin does not define a lifecycle mapping for M2E, which leads to an error marker “Plugin execution not covered by lifecycle configuration”. This is a well known issue when using M2E, and requires some additional work on the plugin. I have opened Bug#366118 for this.

Sample Project

The project described above is shared on Github: https://github.com/kthoms/xtext-experimental

In Eclipse the project looks like this after import (assuming the M2E plugin installed):

Build Execution

The classes in the project can now be built using mvn clean install. This will produce the following output:

[INFO] Scanning for projects...
[INFO] ------------------------------------------------------------------------
[INFO] Building xtend-maven-classic 2.2.0-SNAPSHOT
[INFO] ------------------------------------------------------------------------
[INFO] --- maven-clean-plugin:2.4.1:clean (default-clean) @ xtend-maven-classic ---
[INFO] Deleting /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/target
[INFO] Deleting /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/xtend-gen (includes = [**], excludes = [])
[INFO] --- build-helper-maven-plugin:1.7:add-source (add-source) @ xtend-maven-classic ---
[INFO] Source directory: /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/xtend-gen added.
[INFO] --- xtend-maven-plugin:2.2.0:compile (default) @ xtend-maven-classic ---
WARNING: 	XtendClass1.xtend - /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/src/mypackage/XtendClass1.xtend
7: The value of the field XtendClass1.cls is not used
[INFO] Compiling 1 source file to xtend-gen
[INFO] --- maven-resources-plugin:2.4.3:resources (default-resources) @ xtend-maven-classic ---
[WARNING] Using platform encoding (MacRoman actually) to copy filtered resources, i.e. build is platform dependent!
[INFO] skip non existing resourceDirectory /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/src/main/resources
[INFO] --- maven-compiler-plugin:2.3.2:compile (default-compile) @ xtend-maven-classic ---
[WARNING] File encoding has not been set, using platform encoding MacRoman, i.e. build is platform dependent!
[INFO] Compiling 3 source files to /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/target/classes
[INFO] ------------------------------------------------------------------------
[INFO] ------------------------------------------------------------------------
[INFO] Total time: 3.923s
[INFO] Finished at: Thu Dec 08 23:01:42 CET 2011
[INFO] Final Memory: 20M/81M
[INFO] ------------------------------------------------------------------------

From the output it can be seen that at the end 3 Java classes are compiled, after the xtend-maven-plugin created the Java code for the Xtend class.

Enabling debug output with -X reveals some more insight, how the plugin works:

[DEBUG] Configuring mojo 'org.eclipse.xtend2:xtend-maven-plugin:2.2.0:compile' with basic configurator -->
[DEBUG]   (f) outputDirectory = xtend-gen
[DEBUG]   (f) project = MavenProject: org.eclipse.xtext.example:xtend-maven-classic:2.2.0-SNAPSHOT @ /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/pom.xml
[DEBUG]   (f) tempDirectory = /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/target/xtend
[DEBUG] -- end configuration --
[DEBUG] load xtend file 'file:/Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/src/mypackage/XtendClass1.xtend'
[DEBUG] Parsing took: 42 ms
[DEBUG] create java stub 'mypackage/XtendClass1.java'
[DEBUG] invoke batch compiler with '-cp /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/src:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/org/eclipse/xtend2/org.eclipse.xtend2.lib/2.2.0/org.eclipse.xtend2.lib-2.2.0.jar:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/com/google/guava/guava/10.0.1/guava-10.0.1.jar:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/com/google/code/findbugs/jsr305/1.3.9/jsr305-1.3.9.jar:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/org/eclipse/xtext/org.eclipse.xtext.xtend2.lib/2.2.0.v201112061305/org.eclipse.xtext.xtend2.lib-2.2.0.v201112061305.jar:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/org/eclipse/xtext/org.eclipse.xtext.xbase.lib/2.2.0.v201112061305/org.eclipse.xtext.xbase.lib-2.2.0.v201112061305.jar:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/com/google/inject/com.google.inject/2.0.0.v201105231817/com.google.inject-2.0.0.v201105231817.jar -d /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/target/xtend/classes -1.5 -proceedOnError /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/src /Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/target/xtend/stubs'
[DEBUG] classpath used for Xtend compilation : [file:/Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/src/, file:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/org/eclipse/xtend2/org.eclipse.xtend2.lib/2.2.0/org.eclipse.xtend2.lib-2.2.0.jar, file:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/com/google/guava/guava/10.0.1/guava-10.0.1.jar, file:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/com/google/code/findbugs/jsr305/1.3.9/jsr305-1.3.9.jar, file:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/org/eclipse/xtext/org.eclipse.xtext.xtend2.lib/2.2.0.v201112061305/org.eclipse.xtext.xtend2.lib-2.2.0.v201112061305.jar, file:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/org/eclipse/xtext/org.eclipse.xtext.xbase.lib/2.2.0.v201112061305/org.eclipse.xtext.xbase.lib-2.2.0.v201112061305.jar, file:/Users/thoms/.m2/repository/com/google/inject/com.google.inject/2.0.0.v201105231817/com.google.inject-2.0.0.v201105231817.jar, file:/Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/src/, file:/Users/thoms/git/xtext-experimental/maven/xtend.maven/target/xtend/classes/]

The plugin invokes the Xtend Batch compiler through a spawned JVM. The batch compiler is realized in class org.eclipse.xtext.xtend2.compiler.batch.Xtend2BatchCompiler from the newly added plugin org.eclipse.xtext.xtend2.standalone.

After the build XtendClass1.java is generated as expected to xtend-gen. When opening the target folder it can be seen that the plugin produces a Java stub class to target/stubs for the Xtend class. Finally, everything is compiled and the project is clean :-)


The plugin only takes one source folder into account, namely the one configured by build/sourceDirectory. This is a problem when you have multiple source folders, which is quite typical for Xtext projects, namely src and src-gen. This is reported as , which is fixed in the meantime. I have deployed a patched version as unofficial release 2.2.2.


I deeply desired this plugin and this finally allows that the xtend-gen folder does not need to be checked in. The sample used here was just simple. Next would be a real life project were I want to apply the plugin, most likely in Project Spray. This project uses Xtend based code generation heavily and Maven Tycho for the build. The project has not been upgraded to Xtext 2.2.0 (of course, it was just released), and I guess we have to upgrade to Xtext 2.2.0 before we can use the plugin. But if this allows us to finally remove the xtend-gen folders from the repository this alone is worth upgrading.

Nice work, Xtext team!

Older Posts »

The Silver is the New Black Theme Blog at WordPress.com.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 375 other followers